"Yes, But Is It Good for the Jews?"
MomentMag
The phrase "Yes, but is it good for the Jews?" encapsulates a longstanding maxim within Jewish communities that considers any broader social or political development through the lens of its impact on Jewish interests. This talk by Moment Senior Editor Dan Freedman delves into the historical context and cultural significance of the phrase, highlighting how it has been used to express communal concerns, solidarity, and sometimes humor. The phrase serves as a useful framework for understanding the protective instincts of a community that has historically faced discrimination and various threats while striving for success and integration in diverse society.