The Israel on Campus Coalition, a major pro-Israel organization, monitored a gathering of progressive Jewish students from Open Hillel at Wesleyan University in 2016, using its significant resources and intelligence capabilities to keep an eye on the students advocating for open and inclusive Jewish communities.

The Israel on Campus Coalition (ICC) ran deceptive Facebook campaigns targeting Palestinian-American poet Remi Kanazi during his college campus tours in 2016, depicting him as anti-police and anti-military through fake student-led Facebook pages.

The Israel on Campus Coalition, a mainstream Jewish pro-Israel group, has endorsed the controversial website Canary Mission, known for creating political profiles of pro-Palestinian student activists to deter them from future employment opportunities.